An uncomfortable but simple question. If a parent is approached by authorities and told that the time for their child to be enlisted to serve as a Cohen in the holy temple has gone . But unknowingly to the parents the child is used instead for a pagan ritual child sacrifice “Rachmana Litslan , did the child die “Al kidush Hashem “? Knowing what we know today , especially the knowledge of the actions of the illegal authorities in israel’s when they murdered , without regard thousands of their citizens with a false flag pandemic, bio weapon . Knowing what we know is a soldier enlisting in the Israeli army any different? And what about the parent who does know but tries to convince themselves otherwise, as they send their off child off to the battleground scenario of the an evil regime , what is to be the fate of that parent who does know ?
you won't find a source for that anywhere. Also, these soldiers of the zionist are presumably being killed because they are followers of zionism not because they are jewish.
It should never be referred to as the Jewish state ... ever . It should be referred to as it is the “ secular anti Jewish tyrannical regime “ that corrupted the word Zionism.
BH The Prophet's ahavas yisroel displayed here, as always, is unimaginable. To take all the soldiers who were killed, HY"D, and try to take away their "al kiddush Hashem" status, is extremely heartwarming. May Hashem bless our loving and compassionate Prophet, R' Michoel Green, shlit"a.
Toda Raba Rabbi Green 👏🏻🙂🏆I may not understand all the words in your text, I have a simple mind, yet I do get the profound calling from your soul to stop this scam, that is killing so many humans under the pretext of following G_d's laws!!! Twisted trues and serious brain washing.. So encouraging to read your understanding that others may wake up from this nightmare before is too late for them! G_D protect you and bless you, your integrity, your soul shines through your words 👏🏻🏆💌🕊️
I am once again shocked by your willingness to write long pieces on a Torah subject without having done any apparent Torah research on the subject.
There are clear definitions of "kiddush Hashem" and debate k'derech haTorah, none of which you described anywhere here.
The simplest fundamental of "kiddish Hashem" is when someone has a choice to either shmad or die, and they choose death.
Beyond that foundation, there is speculation on if such status includes one who didn't get to choose but simply accepted his fate with love of Hashem and happy to die.
Some poskim focus on the repentence the comes when one prepares to die, pushing the envelope to any death that a person is aware is comming as likley arousing repentence and therefore "kadosh".
Others focus on the suffereing inherent in any , lo alaini, "misa meshuneh" as being a kapureh for the person, so that would include anyone who, chv"sh, get killed in a car accident as "kadosh".
What is certainly NOT included is someone dying for another religion like zionism. Only those foolish enough to think their evil actions of joining the nazi kapos in germany or the zionist army is eretz yisroel is somehow rutzon Hashem might be able to make a claim. rachmana liba boi.
I think you are missing the point . As painful as the subject is , if it helps just one Jew not to march him or herself in to war under the control of a tyrannical murderous , Jew hating regime , or if it stops just one parent from letting their child sacrifice themselves pointlessly and suicidally on the Evil regimes battleground , it will have been worth it .
Rabbi Green, thank you.
An uncomfortable but simple question. If a parent is approached by authorities and told that the time for their child to be enlisted to serve as a Cohen in the holy temple has gone . But unknowingly to the parents the child is used instead for a pagan ritual child sacrifice “Rachmana Litslan , did the child die “Al kidush Hashem “? Knowing what we know today , especially the knowledge of the actions of the illegal authorities in israel’s when they murdered , without regard thousands of their citizens with a false flag pandemic, bio weapon . Knowing what we know is a soldier enlisting in the Israeli army any different? And what about the parent who does know but tries to convince themselves otherwise, as they send their off child off to the battleground scenario of the an evil regime , what is to be the fate of that parent who does know ?
Any Jew who dies by the hand of a gentile because he or she is jewish , died”Al kidush Hashem “ you need to brush up on your Halacha my friend .
you won't find a source for that anywhere. Also, these soldiers of the zionist are presumably being killed because they are followers of zionism not because they are jewish.
Bottom line don’t willingly serve or allow your children to “serve “ in the anti jewish Zionist army .
It should never be referred to as the Jewish state ... ever . It should be referred to as it is the “ secular anti Jewish tyrannical regime “ that corrupted the word Zionism.
"zionism" is their word, not ours. may we stay far away from their evil.
Brachot dear Rabbi, brachot
BH The Prophet's ahavas yisroel displayed here, as always, is unimaginable. To take all the soldiers who were killed, HY"D, and try to take away their "al kiddush Hashem" status, is extremely heartwarming. May Hashem bless our loving and compassionate Prophet, R' Michoel Green, shlit"a.
what's wrong with you? what does "ahavas yisroel" have to do with the dinim of "al kidush Hashem"?
Toda Raba Rabbi Green 👏🏻🙂🏆I may not understand all the words in your text, I have a simple mind, yet I do get the profound calling from your soul to stop this scam, that is killing so many humans under the pretext of following G_d's laws!!! Twisted trues and serious brain washing.. So encouraging to read your understanding that others may wake up from this nightmare before is too late for them! G_D protect you and bless you, your integrity, your soul shines through your words 👏🏻🏆💌🕊️
Rabbi Green,
I am once again shocked by your willingness to write long pieces on a Torah subject without having done any apparent Torah research on the subject.
There are clear definitions of "kiddush Hashem" and debate k'derech haTorah, none of which you described anywhere here.
The simplest fundamental of "kiddish Hashem" is when someone has a choice to either shmad or die, and they choose death.
Beyond that foundation, there is speculation on if such status includes one who didn't get to choose but simply accepted his fate with love of Hashem and happy to die.
Some poskim focus on the repentence the comes when one prepares to die, pushing the envelope to any death that a person is aware is comming as likley arousing repentence and therefore "kadosh".
Others focus on the suffereing inherent in any , lo alaini, "misa meshuneh" as being a kapureh for the person, so that would include anyone who, chv"sh, get killed in a car accident as "kadosh".
What is certainly NOT included is someone dying for another religion like zionism. Only those foolish enough to think their evil actions of joining the nazi kapos in germany or the zionist army is eretz yisroel is somehow rutzon Hashem might be able to make a claim. rachmana liba boi.
I think you are missing the point . As painful as the subject is , if it helps just one Jew not to march him or herself in to war under the control of a tyrannical murderous , Jew hating regime , or if it stops just one parent from letting their child sacrifice themselves pointlessly and suicidally on the Evil regimes battleground , it will have been worth it .
BH Don't be shocked. R' Michoel Green likes to post whatever is the opposite of conventional wisdom. The more outrageous , the better.
Research, logic, common sense, human decency, etc. are not factors altogether.
don't be disgusting. I meant my comment with the utmost respect to Rabbi Green.
That's nice that you have the utmost respect for him. I'm impressed.
How much vitriolic nonsense from the Prophet do you have to read for the respect level to go down a little?